A Politics of Soul

Building a Coalition of the Heart

Buddhism does not speak much about the soul. It tends to look instead toward impermanence, changeability, and the fluid dynamics of situations. In much of Western civilization, by contrast, the soul has often been imagined as a thing—an independent and perhaps permanent essence that lives on after the body expires.

Buddhism offers another way of approaching the question. It speaks of basic goodness, or Buddha nature: the fundamental openheartedness and wakefulness present in every human being—indeed, in every living being. Basic goodness is not a solid or permanent object. It has always been here precisely because it is always changing, taking new forms and manifesting through people of different cultures, religions, identities, and ways of life.

Perhaps this is closer to what we mean when we describe something as soulful.

Think of soul music. Soul is not a thing possessed by the music. It is an energy moving through it—an energy that connects human beings across cultural boundaries. It is difficult to imagine truly soulful music espousing violence, sectarianism, prejudice, or hatred. Soul music reaches toward something deeper and more universal.

In America, soul music grew from gospel, blending the emotional and spiritual force of the church with the structures and textures of the blues, then moving into the popular music of its time. An extraordinary stream of artists emerged from this fertile meeting place. Among them was Sam Cooke, whose “A Change Is Gonna Come” became one of the defining anthems of the Civil Rights Movement.

The song’s power does not come from political argument alone. It communicates heart to heart. It carries suffering, dignity, longing, and hope across the boundaries that ordinarily divide us. It makes politics human.

A politics of soul would begin there. It would ask whether our political and social structures might be organized around the heart—around our capacity to communicate the feelings of one heart to another, crossing cultural lines and recognizing a shared humanity.

That does not mean pretending prejudice and hatred are superficial or harmless. They can be deeply ingrained in individuals, institutions, and societies. But they are not as deep as our basic goodness. They are not as fundamental as our capacity for openness, wakefulness, and connection.

Even those who espouse hatred, prejudice, or extreme partisanship possess basic goodness. This may be difficult to accept, especially when we feel attacked. Our instinct is often to attack in return. Yet when we answer aggression only with aggression, communication can freeze. Each side becomes more solidly identified as the other’s enemy.

What might happen if, without surrendering our principles or tolerating injustice, we could remove ourselves as targets and speak instead to another person’s basic humanity? What if political communication sought not merely to defeat an opponent, but to reach the place within them that remains capable of recognition and care?

Such an approach would not be sentimental. Opening the heart requires courage, discipline, and clarity. It asks us to resist hatred without becoming organized by hatred ourselves. It asks us to recognize the humanity of people whose actions we may need to oppose.

A politics of soul would not deny conflict. It would transform the ground on which conflict takes place. It would begin from the understanding that beneath our hardened identities and inherited prejudices is a more fundamental capacity to awaken and connect.

Perhaps that is where genuine political change begins: not with the soul as a permanent thing we possess, but with soulfulness as an energy we practice together.

AGING

Learning to Stay Awake Through the 3rd Act

Whether we realize it or not, we are all aging. It is happening even as we speak. And yet I find myself struggling to remain cognizant of that—to identify myself as an older person, or more unsettling, as someone approaching the end of their life.

We die, and don’t know when or how. If life were a casino, it would garner any number of regulatory violations. This is a raw deal any way you look at it. Which leaves us the only way to look at it. Facing it.

My experience of aging hasn’t been a gradual process. It was more like looking in the mirror one day and thinking, My God—is this my face now?

It took some time to get used to that. There can be a lag between realization and assimilation. I think that’s true of many things, but certainly of the aging process. We catch glimpses of it, and they can be startling. But then we push them aside and insist, I’m still a superhero. Stand back!

Realization without assimilation means we are still learning the same lessons again and again. Nothing will change until we sink past the superficial and get to the bone. I’m going to die. And that’s not the bad news. Before we’re swept away into the final urn, we will suffer any number of indignities. I’ve heard it said, “there is nothing dignified about dying.” But, maybe we will no longer care. And maybe I can begin the process of letting go right now so that I might begin to make friends with all of this.

Making friends with death. And all the little creaks and groans leading up to it. If I’m to live a mindful life, I have to pay attention to what is happening in my mind, body and life right now.

Of course, many things pull us out of the present and into dark closets of unresolved fear. There is fear of whatever will happen at the final curtain. Fear of “what dreams may come,” as Shakespeare put it. And there is the pull of regret: the pain of things diminishing, of things we might have done, of memories that can sometimes feel torturous.

For many people, building memories is an important part of their life. I have never quite felt that way myself. Living life merely so I can remember it has always struck me as a little like sitting in a hospital bed watching reruns waiting for the end.

That is not how I want my ending to be.

And make no mistake: for me, this is the end. The last act. I am entering the final period of my life. I feel deeply fortunate to have arrived here—and deeply fortunate to have the Dharma to help me meet and process this experience.

Unfortunately, that doesn’t keep me from bitching about it.

Aging, sickness, and death are part of the experience of being human. I am not alone in this, no matter how shunted, pushed aside, or unseen by society I may sometimes feel. All of us will go through this.

Each of us will either age out or meet a premature sudden end. If I were given the choice, I would choose to age out slowly—and to make of it a long, gradual process of connecting with this profound stage of my life.

Strangely, I hope to not go in my sleep. Have you ever fallen asleep at the end of a movie? I hate that. No, I think it would be best to be aware of the process to the best of my ability. But that’s me.

Perhaps this is about something larger than my own life. It is about the lives of all beings. All life as we understand it—even the life we imagine in distant reaches of space—appears to be temporary. There are stars that explode and stars that slowly diminish into cold darkness. The movement toward death is written into the very nature of life.

In a talk he gave in New York City, Dzigar Kongtrul Rinpoche asked his audience, “How many of you have truly realized that you are going to die someday?” A number of people raised their hands.

Then he asked, “How many of you understand that you are dying right now?”

From the moment we are born, the process of ending is already programmed into our being. And yet we forget. We become lost in the idea that we might still become all the things we imagine ourselves to be, while rarely coming into contact with who we actually are.

Waking in the morning and feeling aches I have never felt before sucks, yes, but it can be an opportunity to see what is happening, as it happens. The pain of again is also an invitation become loving, kind, and patient with my body, perhaps for the first time in my life.

Many of the aches and pains coming to fruition now began as injuries sustained through mindlessness and self-aggression—working out too hard, pushing myself too far.

When I walk down the block and feel the pain in my legs, I panic and then remember this is the time to be with myself. Now is when I need me. And I find with that mindful connection I can adjust my body, sometimes slightly and release the tension.

That sounds small. Certainly smaller than my life used to be when I was too busy to knmow my life. But I find it very profound to have a conversation with my body. Not my body in pain, not the body that was, but my body now. By treating the small pains with kindness may be a step toward being here with myself, trying to stay awake through the final act.

CRITICAL MASS

Pressure and Procrastination as (Poor) Coping Strategies:

The title “Critical Mass” refers to Hexagram 28 of the I Ching, often translated as “Great Exceeding” or “Preponderance of the Great.” Its image is a ridgepole sagging beneath too much weight: strong in the middle but weak at either end. It describes a moment when the structure of things can no longer support the pressure placed upon it.

For me, the image also suggests a breakdown in communication between heaven and earth. In traditional Chinese thought, heaven can represent vision and guiding principle, while earth represents available conditions and resources. Between them stands the human being—the element capable of responding to both.

The heart connects these poles. Through feeling, empathy, and compassion, we negotiate between what we believe we should do and what we can actually do.

Stress and traumatic fear can interrupt that connection. The body contracts, our perspective narrows, and clear thought becomes harder to translate into action. We may know what needs to be done without knowing how. For some of us, this leads to procrastination and avoidance until everything undone seems ready to collapse around us.

As pressure builds, survival instincts take over. We want to flee, freeze, or fight our way out. Yet when we reach the breaking point, some of us rise to the occasion and begin the heroic work of digging ourselves out. Urgency organizes us. What matters becomes obvious. The next step becomes unavoidable. We spend less time negotiating with ourselves and more time responding to what is needed.

It’s a shame that we sometimes need panic to reach clarity. But when the pattern repeats, instead of approaching it with acceptance and curiosity, we berate ourselves. We decide that we’re lazy, dysfunctional, delusional, or damaged. We spend time and money on remedies and programs that don’t work, reinforcing the belief that we alone—despite the millions of people who struggle this way—are broken.

Then life quiets down, and the last thing we want to do is get to work. Space provides the opposite of pressure: room to postpone, to wait until we feel ready. But when will we feel ready? When we’ve lost the weight? Found the right eye cream? Made yet another “2 Do” list? Reorganized the 2Do list again?

I’ve come to realize that “2 Do” lists are where my aspirations go to die. We sometimes feel we don’t know how to care for ourselves. Maybe that’s because we’re not really here with ourselves. We’re caught up in patterns of procrastination, guilt, false starts, fails and angry avoidance.These patterns are driven by anxiety and they have deep roots. But we don’t need to identify every cause before we begin working with them. We can start with what’s here.

Can we learn to show up before life forces us to? That’s where meditation comes in. We sit down and discover what is actually here. We stop chasing theories and adding bullet points to our notepad. We stop and see what is happening now.

Maybe we discover that we don’t want to be there. We’re restless and uncomfortable. We have a million other things to do. We keep jumping off the cushion because pausing amid so much urgency feels absurd.

But perhaps that is exactly what we need: to look at the panic with love and remain present with ourselves.

This is how we begin to reconnect with the ground beneath us and recover our capacity for clear action—not by obeying the panic, but by staying with it until it settles and our view becomes clearer.

Pema Chödrön calls this “learning to stay.” It takes practice. We practice staying with whatever arises, holding it in the open arms of love rather than squeezing it in panic or running away.

At some point, we may discover the mountain-like stillness within us. The mountain remains still even when storms rage across it. The mountain is powerful in it’s stillness. But the mountain did not acquire its strength overnight. It grew into it over time.

We can bring that practice into everyday life. Notice the reluctance and the desire to escape into something easier. Give those feelings room, and then choose one small action: open the document, write the first sentence, or make the call.

A clear starting time, a manageable commitment, or someone who knows what you intend to do may help. These things create a reason to begin before the emergency arrives.

We can also learn to distinguish between resting and avoiding, between being kind to ourselves and abandoning ourselves. Learning to stay means not abandoning our lives simply because they feel difficult. In fact, that may be when we most need to remain present for ourselves.

We don’t have to wait until everything becomes overwhelming before caring for what matters. We can begin now, with the next right thing, one step at a time.

Getting things done, might be more about slowing down, relaxing, and forgiving than forging ahead. It may be more about being here than anywhere we might be going.

The War on Awakening

Some are calling for a “war on woke.” Why are people so threatened by the idea? Admittedly, the term is meant to be provocative, still I can’t help feeling that parts of society harbor an underlying fear of being awake.

What is “waking up”?

Is it seeing past the firewall of self-perception or beyond the structures that govern our lives? If this were the case, then it would certainly be threatening to established structures – especially when those structures have developed to maintain a status quo. While it’s entertaining to throw blind darts toward secret cabals, as meditators we always look to our own mind and psychology.

Shadow governments aside, how are we actually controlling ourselves? What is our experience of hiding behind concepts, ideas and prejudice for safety – often to find a perceived higher ground of judgement?

Stories about awakening and seeing behind the curtain are common themes in literature and movies. From The Matrix, throughout much of science fiction, conspiracy theories and popular culture, we’re fascinated by the trope of our being held at bay by whomever we deem to be holding us. We are being held away from the truth.

Perhaps this dates back to the tree of the knowledge of good and evil in the Garden of Eden. Once Adam and Eve were forbidden to eat the forbidden fruit, a seed—an apple seed, we might say—was planted in their minds. It was only as matter of time. As these were the first people, maybe God was still working things out. But, most of us know that telling someone they can’t do some its a sure way of getting them to do it. gave not In the patriarchal telling, it is the woman who becomes both tempted and temptress, pulling the man from his resolve and toward our demise. Once Eve fell for the snake – and what do you suppose that represents? – and convinced Adam to follow,

Through Eve’s sexual awakening a crack happened in the existential frame of the garden. Allowing perhaps chaos, or maybe light.

Either way everything changed in that instant. And, of course, this is all the lady’s fault. Buddhist scripture offers a striking contrast. In Tibetan Vajrayana, transformative feminine energy is equally disruptive but this fissuring of the conceptual frame—or waking up—is seen as essential to our development of awareness and compassion. This energy is often embodied by the dakini, or “sky dancer,” a beautiful young woman whose role is to seduce people beyond their rigid ideas. Far from blaming the feminine, the tradition exalts her.

There is a wonderful story about Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche, one of the most revered Tibetan teachers of his time. He stood over six feet tall—“two and a half Tibetans,” as my teacher put it—and in his later years often walked with his hands resting on his attendants’ shoulders.

During a very important empowerment in front of dignitaries, diplomats and students, the great man’s wife burst into the shrine room and began to berate him for some domestic injustice or other. She walked straight toward the shrine, yelling as the ceremony approached its most sacred point. I do not know what had angered her. Dilgo Khyentse simply looked to her and smiled, his face beaming with love.

Years ago, I was driving on an interstate in Maine with my then-partner when the hood of our jalopy came loose and slammed against the windshield. It happened instantly and was literally breathtaking. I managed to reach the shoulder without hitting anything. My heart pounding, I leapt out and began violently ripping the hood from the car, cutting my hands in the process, red-faced and furious.

Then I looked to my partner, a senior Vajrayana teacher and in many ways my teacher, as she stood outside the car that had nearly killed us, laughing. With the same loving gaze I imagine Dilgo Khyentse offering his wife, she said, “We handle surprises entirely differently.”

We cling to our conceptual frameworks with a tenacity that keeps us in the dark, or at least the semi-dark land of habit.

So what is the problem with waking up?

Meditation teachers describe awakening as refining the mind to see beyond constraining frames. Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche said the only difference between the dreams of sleep and the dream of our ordinary life is duration. Most of us are dreaming most of the time, with only occasional cracks in the facade: a car accident, a breakup, a grave diagnosis.

From the perspective of our attachment to life as we know it, these events are terrible. Yet they may also offer the possibility of awakening—and for a Buddhist, awakening is everything. Even people with deep understanding and strong moral principles still have farther to go if they cannot see beyond those principles toward a truth that helps them communicate with the world as it is. Compassion is communication and communication requires us to look beyond our premises.

What, then, of the war on woke? Some see it as a campaign against chaos. Sometimes it may be. But it may also express a fear of opening the mind and heart to wisdom, to the knowledge of good and evil. Christianity and the Judeo-Christian traditions contain many beautiful, instructive, and transformative elements. Yet, one contrast is that the progenitors of the human race were warned not to look into the mechanism of their existence. Buddhism makes looking its central purpose.

This is not an argument that one tradition is right and the other wrong. It is an illustration: some social structures are designed to preserve order and control; other forces tear open the fabric so that the butterfly can leave the cocoon. The sanest view employs both. We need enough structure to feel secure and to communicate with one another. But when we grip that structure with white-knuckled fury and refuse to let anything new enter, we tighten our eyes and keep ourselves asleep.

Remaining asleep is not as easy as it sounds. We must squint, look away, and actually work not to see.

I imagine that if there were a God, they might point to reality and say, “It has been here all along. Why did you not look? Why did you not see?” Of course, the answer might be, “Because you told us not to.”

But that is another story.

Ultra-conservative movements, including those now exercising power in the government of the country where I live, maintain control by demonizing agents of change. They are agents of fear, fearful themselves and capitalizing on the fears of others. Witches, artists, transformational priestesses, shamans and those who revere nature have long been vilified or struck down for looking beyond established social, political, and religious structures.

You can control a mumbling crowd looking to the ground more than a group of people fostering the power of the earth.

Perhaps because I have attention deficit disorder, I tire quickly of the old tropes used to keep people from thinking. Unexamined stupidity seems to reproduce itself. The real struggle is not against every existing structure. It is against the structures we carry within ourselves by finding the essence of love within. Love allows us to open our eyes. Trungpa Rinpoche said, “Look, look. This is your life. How can you not look?”

To risk a cliché: love is stronger than hate. It may not feel as forceful in the moment as panic or fury, but people who traffic in hate are most likely frightened and insecure. Loving them may be a tall order. Yet refusing to be cowed by their fear—and allowing our own love to develop into empathy—is our transformational imperative.

Holding to beliefs, outrage, or righteous bias with white knuckled fury keeps us from seeing the alternatives around us. We’re using our passion to entirely miss the point.

My indignation about the gross master betas masquerading as strong leaders is understandable, but limited. It keeps me communicating with others in my garden, but not at all with those I wish to influence.

Letting go is the operative action in allowing ourselves to wake up. It’s actually harder to stay asleep. Let go and see the garden, you might say.

So, as Elvis might say, what’s so funny about waking up?

___________

Understanding Karma

Turning the Mind Toward Freedom

Karma is one of the four reminders. The others are the preciousness of human life, impermanence and death, and the unsatisfactory nature of samsara. Together, these contemplations wake us up to our situation and how we create a path to liberation or further embed ourselves in suffering.

This life gives us a rare opportunity to practice. It will not last forever. Our actions have consequences. And habitual acts caused by grasping and fixation cannot provide lasting satisfaction.

Today we’re looking at Karma. People sometimes say “karma is a bitch”. But karma is actually good news. Understanding how we create and live the dynamics of our actions shows us where change is possible. We can pray for guidance and strength, but we actually have the ability to effect change in our lives each moment.

The word “karma” means action. It refers to actions of body, speech, and mind that arise from particular motivations and lead to particular results. Karma is sometimes misunderstood as fate or punishment. When something painful happens, we say, “That must be my karma,” as if karma meant that by suffering we were proven guilty.

But karma is not a system of cosmic reward and punishment. It is a teaching about cause and effect. Certain intentions and actions tend to produce suffering while others tend to toward well-being and freedom. A challenge lies in the way many actions that produce suffering appear to be beneficial at first glance. They are wolves in sheeps lingerie, so to speak. How often do the things we want, need or feel obliged to actually further indebt us to the momentum of samsara?

The conditions of the present have been shaped by many causes, some of which are beyond our knowledge or control. Yet our response in this moment becomes a new cause and that cause will plant the seed for the next condition. We have a choice: we can blindly go along with the momentum we’re generated, or make an active, conscious choice.

Hence, Karma is not our fault, but it is our responsibility. And it is an opportunity for us to wake up and gain agency in our lives. The point is we are conditioned, but not helpless.

Let’s look at our life. Suppose someone criticizes us. Before we have time to think, the body tightens and the mind begins preparing a defense. Perhaps we interrupt, attack the other person, or withdraw into cold silence. The exchange may last only a few minutes, but something has been reinforced. We have strengthened the habit of meeting discomfort with defensiveness.

And, as actions condition the likelihood of their recurrence, the next time criticism comes, that response may arise even more quickly.

Grasping becomes action, actions become habits, and habits shape the world we experience. If we repeatedly rehearse resentment, we inhabit an increasingly resentful mind. If we practice generosity, patience, or honesty, those qualities become more available to us.

Even our thoughts have this quality. A difficult thought may arise without invitation, but what happens next matters. Do we feed it, repeat it, and build an identity around it? Or do we recognize it as a passing mental event and allow it to dissolve?

We may not be responsible for every thought that appears, but we can learn to take responsibility for what we cultivate. Working with Karma is as if we were to become gardeners of the soul. We plant seeds and experience what has been sown. And we fertilize our actions by intention. Were we awake and making a mindful decision to benefit ourselves and others? Or were we acting out of habitual blind reaction? Were we acting our of selflessness or selfishness?

Therefore, in considering karma, intention is crucial. We might give someone a gift out of genuine care, out of obligation, or because we want to control how they see us. The visible action is the same, but the imprint on the mind is different.

Before an important action, we can pause and ask, “What is moving me right now?” Is it kindness? Fear? Pride? Anger? The wish to be admired? The wish to help? We ask because seeing our motivation offers us agency.

A useful practice is to bring three questions into daily life:

  1. What is my intention?
  2. What habit will this action strengthen?
  3. Is this likely to reduce suffering or increase it?

We can ask these questions before sending a heated message, repeating gossip, making a purchase, or entering an argument. We can also ask them before a generous act, so that we consciously recognize and strengthen what is beneficial.

Karma does not concern only dramatic moral decisions. Much of our life is shaped by small, repeated actions. Do we reach for our phone whenever we feel uncomfortable? Do we speak impatiently to the people closest to us? Do we avoid responsibilities and then create explanations for why we could not fulfill them?

On the beneficial side, do we express gratitude? Do we listen without planning our response? Do we refrain from a harsh word? Do we admit when we are wrong?

And, as we’ve seen, every repetition strengthens a direction.

We become angry to protect ourselves, but the anger disturbs our minds and damages our relationships. We grasp at pleasant experiences, but our fear of losing them prevents us from resting. We defend a fixed image of ourselves, but then we must constantly protect it.

To turn away from samsara is to become less willing to live automatically inside these patterns.

This does not mean turning away from family, work, enjoyment, or ordinary life. It means turning away from the habits that keep producing suffering. Ordinary life becomes the place of practice.

Of course, we will continue to make mistakes. The teaching on karma should not lead to guilt, fear, or obsessive self-monitoring. Guilt often says, “I am bad.” Wise regret says, “That action caused harm, and I want to choose differently.”

Here is a contemplation whenever we recognize a harmful thought, action or consequence:

  • First, acknowledge honestly what happened. Second, allow genuine regret—not self-hatred, but a clear recognition of the consequences. Third, repair the harm where possible. Fourth, form a specific intention for what we will do differently.
  • This process interrupts the tendency either to deny our actions or to define ourselves permanently by them. Karma means actions have consequences, but it also means new actions can create new conditions.

A short evening review can make this teaching very concrete. At the end of the day, take five minutes.

  • Ask, “Where did I act today from generosity, patience, honesty, or compassion?” Appreciate those moments. Rejoicing in beneficial action helps strengthen it.
  • Then ask, “Where did I act from grasping, aversion, or confusion?” Look clearly, without excuses and without hostility. Choose one situation and imagine a wiser response. If repair is needed, decide how to begin it.
  • Finally, set one intention for tomorrow.
  • The other reminders support this practice. Precious human life tells us that we have the capacity to choose. Impermanence tells us not to postpone the work. The suffering of samsara shows us what happens when we continue acting unconsciously. But karma brings the teaching directly into this moment.

When a situation arises that we choose to look in to, pause for one breath. Feel what is happening in the body. Notice the motivation. Ask, “What am I about to strengthen?”

Then choose the next action as carefully as you can.

Liberation may seem vast or distant. But its direction is established very close to home: in the intentions we cultivate, the habits we interrupt, the harm we repair, and the next choice we make.

So, if Karma is a bitch, then it’s our bitch. It is our way of navigating from suffering in samsara toward liberation.